My Cocktail Pantry

Guide

The home bartender’s starter kit

· My Cocktail Pantry

Boulevardier cocktail in a rocks glass — bourbon, Campari, and sweet vermouth from a short home bar

A home bar does not start with 30 bottles. It starts with three spirits you will actually finish, then the smallest set of extras that turn those bottles into a menu. Counted against every recipe on My Cocktail Pantry, that set is gin, bourbon, and white rum, plus seven extras: lemon, lime, simple syrup, soda water, dry vermouth, sweet vermouth, and Campari. Ten items. Twelve recipes you can mark Ready to Mix — including the Boulevardier, Negroni, Daiquiri, and Martini.

The three spirits: gin, bourbon, and white rum

Gin, whiskey, and rum are the old three-bottle bar. On this site the whiskey is bourbon and the rum is white rum — not because rye and dark rum are worse, but because those two labels unlock the most complete recipes from a first purchase. Bourbon satisfies every drink that asks for generic whiskey (the Whiskey Sour) and every drink that names bourbon (the Boulevardier). White rum covers the Daiquiri and any recipe that just says rum. Gin is the third leg: Martinis, Negronis, Gimlets, Collinses, and Fizzes all start there.

Vodka as the third spirit instead of rum trades the Daiquiri for a Vodka Soda and a Vodka Martini. That is a real menu, and it is one drink larger in this catalog, but it is a thinner bartender’s kit: you lose the shaken rum sour that teaches the same technique as the Gimlet and the Whiskey Sour. Tequila and cognac wait. They are fourth bottles, not first three. Add gin, bourbon, and white rum in Pantry before you buy anything else.

Four extras that make sours and Collinses

Lemon, lime, simple syrup, and soda water are the four extras that do the heavy lifting. Lemon plus syrup plus gin or bourbon pours a Whiskey Sour, a Tom Collins, a Gin Fizz, and a John Collins. Lime plus syrup plus rum or gin pours a Daiquiri and a Gimlet. Soda is what splits a sour from a Collins or a Fizz: shake gin, lemon, and syrup, then soda in a tall glass — ice in the glass for a Tom Collins, no ice for a Gin Fizz.

Buy both citrus. Lemon and lime are not interchangeable in this catalog, and swapping them drops three or four Ready to Mix drinks at a stroke. Simple syrup is the sweetener that matches almost every sour here; a sugar cube is a different ingredient and is not in this kit (that is why the Old Fashioned is not on the list — more on that below). Club soda or soda water is the same bottle. Keep it cold.

With only the three spirits and these four extras you already have seven recipes: Daiquiri, Gimlet, Whiskey Sour, Tom Collins, Gin Fizz, John Collins, and a Virgin Daiquiri if you want the lime-and-syrup mocktail. That is the sour layer. The next three extras are what turn the same gin and bourbon into stirred bitter drinks.

Three extras that make Martinis and Negronis

Dry vermouth is the seventh extra if you are counting from zero, and it has one job: the Martini. Gin and dry vermouth, stirred, up. No citrus. It is the cheapest extra on the list relative to how often you will use gin, and it is the drink people mean when they ask whether you can mix a cocktail.

Sweet vermouth and Campari are the pair. Together they unlock the Negroni (gin), the Boulevardier (bourbon), the Americano (Campari, sweet vermouth, soda — no extra spirit), and the Milano-Torino (Campari and sweet vermouth, no soda). Drop either bottle and those four drinks leave Ready to Mix together. Sweet vermouth alone, without Campari, does not unlock a new complete recipe in this kit. Buy them as a pair.

That is seven extras, not eight. An eighth bottle of Angostura or triple sec sounds like “starter kit” folklore, but against this catalog Angostura unlocks nothing until you also add sugar, and triple sec only adds a White Lady. Campari plus two vermouths adds four drinks. Counted that way, seven is the stop.

The 12 recipes this kit pours

Shaken sours: Daiquiri (white rum, lime, syrup), Gimlet (gin, lime, syrup), Whiskey Sour (bourbon, lemon, syrup). Tall gin drinks: Tom Collins and Gin Fizz (gin, lemon, syrup, soda — ice vs no ice), plus the John Collins if you want the London-dry twin of the Tom. Stirred and bitter: Martini, Negroni, Boulevardier, Americano, Milano-Torino. And the Virgin Daiquiri from lime and syrup if the rum stays in the cabinet.

Four of those pages are already impression-leading recipes in Search Console: Boulevardier, Tom Collins, Gin Fizz, and Gimlet. The kit is built so those URLs, plus the Negroni and Daiquiri, are drinks you can actually make — not a shopping list that still needs a liqueur you do not own. Open What I can make after you check the ten items off in Pantry; they should land in Ready to Mix.

What this kit skips on purpose

The Old Fashioned is missing because it wants a sugar cube and Angostura bitters, not simple syrup. Sugar and simple syrup stay distinct on this site — that is deliberate, so an Old Fashioned does not pretend a Daiquiri sweetener is enough. Add those two extras later if the bourbon bottle is the one you reach for most.

Mint would add a Mojito, a Mint Julep, and a Southside, but it is produce with a short life, and it does not replace Campari. Dark rum, rye, vodka, tonic, and cola each unlock one famous highball (Dark ’n’ Stormy, Sazerac-adjacent rye drinks, Vodka Soda, Gin & Tonic, Cuba Libre) and none of them match seven extras that already pour twelve recipes. They are the next shopping-list row, not the starter kit.

Put the kit in Pantry and see the menu

Check off gin, bourbon, white rum, lemon, lime, simple syrup, soda water, dry vermouth, sweet vermouth, and Campari. Then open What I can make. Ready to Mix should show the twelve. Almost There will show the Old Fashioned (sugar and bitters), the Cuba Libre (cola), and other near-misses ranked by how many bottles they still need.

When you are ready to grow past ten items, Shopping list ranks the next buy by how many complete recipes it unlocks from the bottles you already own — the same math this kit used, personalized to your shelf. Until then, three spirits and seven extras are enough to mix tonight.

Stock gin, bourbon, and white rum. Add lemon, lime, simple syrup, soda, two vermouths, and Campari. That is the home bartender’s starter kit on this site: ten items, twelve recipes, including a Boulevardier if the bourbon is already on the shelf. Start in Pantry, then drink through What I can make.

Stock your pantry See what you can make Browse all recipes

Frequently asked questions

What three spirits should I buy first for a home bar?

Gin, bourbon, and white rum. Counted against this catalog, that trio plus seven extras unlocks 12 complete recipes. Vodka as the third spirit instead of rum swaps the Daiquiri for a Vodka Soda and a Vodka Martini; rum is the better teaching bottle.

What is the smallest set of extra ingredients that unlocks the most cocktails?

Seven extras: lemon, lime, simple syrup, soda water, dry vermouth, sweet vermouth, and Campari. Six extras (dropping dry vermouth) still pour 11 recipes; the seventh extra is the Martini. An eighth bottle of Angostura or triple sec adds less than Campari plus the two vermouths.

Why isn’t the Old Fashioned in the starter kit?

It needs a sugar cube and Angostura bitters. Simple syrup does not count as sugar on this site, so those two extras are a later trip, not part of the first ten items.

Can I use rye instead of bourbon, or dark rum instead of white?

Rye will not unlock the Boulevardier — that recipe names bourbon. It will cover a Whiskey Sour, which asks for generic whiskey. Dark rum will not unlock a Daiquiri; white rum will not unlock a Dark ’n’ Stormy. Buy the labels the recipes name.